Sunday, 29 September 2013

Is there justice in basketball in Victoria?

This is a cautionary tale about a mother, a daughter, a family, a team and their brush with bureaucracy and the failure of the system in a basketball club.


Sometimes things happen that are beyond your control.  You may be the innocent party, but  justice is not done.
Recently a mother received a call from one of her daughter’s teammates. She asked the mother to come to the basketball stadium immediately as her daughter had been injured during her game in the midweek women's competition. An ambulance had been called. The mother was on the scene within minutes. The daughter was lying on the floor in great pain and distress.
First aid precautions meant she had to remain where she was, without movement, due to the possibility of neck and back injuries.
The mother was told there had been a young referee and a trainee referee under the supervision of an A Grade referee on that game. The A Grade referee did not have a whistle, so control of the game was left entirely to two referees with inadequate qualifications and experience. Apparently referees supervising a junior or trainee are not supposed to blow for fouls. 
The daughter’s injuries occurred when she was shooting for goal, and was leaping with both feet off the floor. A player from the opposing team charged her from the side with such force she was rammed into the brick wall - a distance in excess of four metres. Unfortunately this was not within the padded area. Her shoulder, arm and torso took the impact with the wall. She then dropped to the floor - without being able to regain her feet - and took the impact of the floor on her pelvis and thigh. The opposition player involved was given an ‘Unsportsmanlike Foul’ and had already left the stadium. The A Grade referee told the mother that the player involved would be reported. The other player’s ‘unsportsmanlike foul’ was a clear indication her actions were intentional. At the very least, her actions were dangerous. 

When the ambulance arrived, the daughter needed morphine for pain. She was fitted with a neck brace, carefully conveyed to the ambulance, and transported to a nearby Hospital Emergency Department. Before the ambulance left, Her husband arrived, and he accompanied her in the ambulance, while the mother followed in her car. 
While in the Emergency Department, the daughter was again was administered with painkillers, two more times.
When the Emergency doctor was eventually able to examine the daughter, he determined there were no breakages, however there was considerable dislocation/whiplash, bruising and muscular-skeletal strain and soreness. Fortunately the daughter is young, healthy and fit or her prognosis may have been more negative. 
The daughter eventually left the Emergency Department at 3.30am the next morning.
The bruise on the daughter's right hip/thigh
The bruise on the daughter's right arm.
She had to take several days off work, which is a considerable disadvantage for her job at the end of the Financial Year. She still requires ongoing medical support (two months after the incident), including physiotherapy, etcetera. She will also miss her income as a referee, as well as being unfit to play. 
Her husband has also had to take time off work to care for her.
The mother also had very little sleep that night.
They will never get that time back. Basketball insurance does not cover loss of casual income.
The family has many years of association with the basketball club, in various roles, and realise that a large club has a great and ongoing need for referees. But insufficient training and maintenance of standards does not attract or retain good referees. A higher standard of refereeing will result in more control of games and less injuries and player frustration. 
To her family, the daughter is precious. They do not want her to suffer permanent disability, which could have been the result of this incident. Long term medical implications of this injury are still to be revealed.
That evening was a very frightening time for the family, but their frustration and sense of betrayal had only just begun.
The following Saturday, when the mother was the venue supervisor, the same referee spoke to her and said he was would not report the player as he had not seen the incident, because he was talking to his trainee referee at the time. The daughter and the mother then both submitted complaints to the Club, and the club’s complaints officer spoke to them. He put in a report on the daughter’s behalf, as he felt that an injury requiring an ambulance, needed to be reported.
At no time did any representative of the club contact the daughter personally regarding her welfare or personal wellbeing. She only heard about the prospect of a Tribunal hearing through the mother, when she heard it in conversation at the club. The daughter was never officially told about the Tribunal, or advised how to proceed, or how many witnesses to bring, and what evidence she should provide. 
The Tribunal hearing was held on a Tuesday evening.
The player involved admitted she had caused the foul. She argued she did not think she had hit the daughter that hard. The player who caused the injuries was supported by two witnesses - one who agreed with her, and one whose testimony was thrown out as it contradicted the reported player’s testimony.
The daughter testified, as did another member from her team, who had seen the incident. As the daughter had not received official notice of the Tribunal hearing, she was unable to give enough notice to another of her teammates, who was closest to the incident on the court, and was in the best position to see the incident. The teammate had a work commitment.
When the Senior Referee gave his testimony he then changed his story and claimed he’d seen the incident and said that the reported player had not pushed that hard, despite the daughter’s obvious injuries and the distance she was thrown. Did he change his story to deflect attention from the fact he was not doing an adequate job as a referee?
Due to the Senior referee’s inconsistent testimony the complaint on the reported player was dismissed by the Tribunal. The Senior referee’s failure to make a report on the night of the injury prejudiced the case, as the Tribunal perceived that he had considered the action as lacking intent, despite the fact he had stated to the mother that he had not seen the incident.
The family were very upset and contacted the Complaints Officer who advised that the daughter could appeal to Basketball Victoria. But members of the club’s committee, who made no effort to contact the daughter to clarify details, decided the matter had been dealt with in-house and they did not support the appeal. She was told that without the committee’s support the appeal would not proceed.
The daughter was subsequently advised to write to Basketball Victoria and state her reasons for wanting an appeal of the Tribunal’s decision.
Below were the daughter's reasons for appealing the Tribunal’s decision:
  1. She was never officially informed of Tribunal hearing.
  2. She was never told about the time of the Tribunal. The mother heard unofficially and had to confirm details. No one in the family received written notification of the Tribunal.
  3. Confirmation of the time of the Tribunal was too late for the daughter to organise her best witness, although she did manage to bring another witness supporting her complaint.
  4. Inconsistent testimony of the Senior Referee led to a dismissal of the report - regardless of the admission of the player who injured the daughter, or her medical evidence, witness and testimony. 
  5. The Senior Referee flip-flopped. He stated that a report would be made at the time of the incident, but later claimed to have not seen the incident as he was instructing a rookie referee on court. He was a reluctant witness as he stated he did not want to testify at the Tribunal. His evidence was suspect. His inconsistent testimony led the Tribunal to dismiss the case because the player had not been reported 'on the day'.
  6. The Senior Referee was not instructed by the club of his responsibilities to players when an injury requiring an ambulance has occurred.
  7. The junior referees were not mentored regarding the Tribunal. 
  8. The Club had no protocol to ensure the well-being of injured parties or to support them during Tribunal hearings.
  9. Despite being a member of the club for many years, and serving the club in many capacities, the committee at no time has inquired personally about the daughter’s wellbeing and did not support her appearance at the Tribunal or her subsequent appeal.
  10. The Tribunal refused to visit the basketball court, where the incident took place, to allow the daughter to demonstrate the distance she was pushed.
  11. The Complaints Officer supported the appeal.
  12. The Referee coordinator also suggested a personal appeal.
The daughter played basketball at that club for many years. She is also an A Grade referee. She is distressed that this part of her life is now over.

As a result of this incident:
  1. The daughter has been unable to play since the incident (now nearly 2 months ago) due to her injury. She may never play basketball again.
  2. The daughter is still receiving regular medical and allied health attention for her injuries.
  3. The daughter has lost income as a referee
  4. The daughter will not play or referee for that club again.
  5. The daughter was forced to have days off from her regular employment.
  6. The daughter is spending considerable time at medical appointments.
  7. The mother has resigned her position at the Club, which has also meant a loss of income. The mother could not continue to work with that referee or that unsupportive club.
  8. The reported player involved received no penalty, reprimand or warning and continues to play.
  9. The referee involved has never addressed the issue.
  10. The Club’s committee has denied the daughter natural justice and showed no concern for her welfare.
  11. The Club appears to have no protocols for dealing with these matters.
The family is disappointed in the lack of concern that the club has paid to their daughter’s grievance.  
The club has lost a family of loyal members, employees, volunteers and supporters. 

In early August the family received a standard form-letter reply from Basketball Victoria.
It said:

Unfortunately, outcomes of the Tribunal process are not always what people expect of them.  Our Tribunal volunteers have a very difficult job to perform and can only make a decision based on the evidence before them.  Obviously, on this occasion, they did not believe there was sufficient evidence to find the other player guilty of any offence. 

Under the Tribunal By-laws there is a limited right to review.  You can view that procedure also on our web site at By-law 21 of the By-laws.  The link is http://www.basketballvictoria.com.au/index.php?id=87

You will see from the By-laws that any request for review must have the endorsement of the Board of the basketball association.  I note that this has been taken to the [Club's] Board and the Board has decided not to request such a review.

It is not within my or Basketball Victoria’s power to otherwise intervene in the Tribunal process.

All this could have been avoided if the Senior Referee on the night has done what he said he would do – report the player, and tell the truth. His actions prejudiced the whole sequence of events.

Lesson from this sorry tale: If your child or adult family member is injured during a basketball match and you feel the action was intentional, make sure that the referee makes a report AT THE TIME OF THE INCIDENT or nothing will come of it. 

Footnote: The daughter has since joined a gym. This will keep her fit and help with her rehabilitation.
She still keeps in touch with her teammates.

Saturday, 24 August 2013

Life with a teenage daughter - Changes in the Kingdom

Watercolour by L. Wilks

When our daughter was sixteen, life as we knew it changed forever in our household. What happened? What calamity befell us? Was there a death? Did someone lose their job? Was the dog pregnant?
Nothing that minor!
Once upon a time our teenage daughter had been a free spirit, a golden haired princess who ran to meet us when we came home, who asked if we wanted a cuppa, who usually needed to be driven somewhere. Suddenly she had this large growth on her side. It was called ‘a boyfriend’.
It was quiet romantic really. He saw her across a crowded basketball stadium and sent a go-between to ask her to meet him in the foyer at half time. Introductions were made. Phone numbers exchanged. Calls were made. He became a fixture.
He was a nice enough guy. Tall. Handsome. Courteous. (Or was I just being suspicious?)
It seems our Little Princess had grown up. She was spending large amounts of time preening in front of the mirror, talking on the phone and watching TV romances.
She had developed an interest in things that she wouldn’t give two minutes to some month earlier. Films that HE liked. Food that HE liked. Books that HE liked. (Well, there had to be some side benefits!)
As her parents, we adjusted. We learned to share. We’d always thought our daughter was beautiful, but it’s different when someone else thinks it. Apart from sharing our daughter with a boy we hardly knew, we had to share our home with the enormous fluffy toy he gave her on Valentine’s Day. It usually sat on her bed, but could be found abandoned anywhere about the house. At least it didn’t require feeding like her other pets that looked at me pathetically wondering where all her hugs and kisses had gone.
What were we supposed do?
What did my parents do? My Mum had interrogated all boys on their family history, when they crossed our front doorstep. The bare light globe often blinded them because they groped around a lot afterwards.
My Dad used to called every boy I brought home, ‘George’. On one memorable occasion, Dad hosed down a boy as he attempted the journey to the front door. Dad said he was just watering the garden. Yeah, Right!
As modern parents we were not going to be like that.
We’d play it cool. We wouldn’t play our hand too early. If we approved we’d be pushy. If we disapproved we’d drive her further into his arms.
We didn’t want to be the overprotective, nervous wrecks our parents were, when we were her age. We would do the modern thing. We would remain calm. If we took enough sleeping tablets we could just about get to sleep while we waited for her to get home. Almost!
She played it by the book. She even arranged the formal introduction. ‘Mum, Dad, this is Prince Charming. Prince Charming, this is Mum and Dad.’
Before this momentous occasion we were told firmly not to ask him too many questions. We stood like cardboard cut-out parents wondering what this boy wanted to do when he grew up, what subjects he liked at school, what footy team he supported. (That’s an important question in our home.)
These questions and a thousand more had to wait. The Princess had spoken.
After the first date I asked her if he’d kissed her. Did she like it?
She looked at me shocked. ‘It’s just too weird to talk to you about that. You’re an parent!’
What happened to all those parenting courses, those family round table discussions, those girl-to-girl chats we’d had? Had they amounted to nothing? Were these topics we would never discuss again?
It’s not that we didn’t trust The Princess. We trusted her with our lives. We could endure anything after her first driving lesson. It’s all that male testosterone we were worried about. Were all his gifts and attention aimed at a payoff? Where could we get a good sequined chastity belt for the Modern Miss?
Then I thought about his mum. Was she his taxi service, as we were hers? Did she deliver her son to our Den of Seduction and hope this Teenage Temptress would not lead her Charming Prince astray? Princes need to study too, you know.
I remembered some of the things I did when I was her age that my Mum and Dad didn’t know about. Then I really was worried. Should I suggest that my husband water the garden on date night?
I shoved that enormous fluffy animal to the back of her wardrobe. I hoped the tiara wasn’t too uncomfortable for him.
Years have passed. Prince Charming has moved on. The large fluffy toy departed during a garage sale.
A King of Hearts entered the Princess’s life and stole her heart.
As her parents, we have learned to share our beautiful daughter with a man who she loves, and who loves her. And delight, delight! The girl-to-girl chats have returned, but they are Woman-to-Woman chats now. She now thinks of her parents as more than chauffeurs and financiers.  The fluffy toy dog has been replaced with a breathing menagerie. The Princess has grown up. She is a Queen of Hearts. 

Friday, 9 August 2013

Whale watching off Coolangatta, Australia - July 2013


Photos by Steve Triance (the cruise photographer), as my photos where not as spectacular. My digital has a short shutter delay and I sometimes missed the action. My photos were similar but not as good quality. Steve had an SLR with tonnes of lenses.


Whale watching  was a highlight of our recent holiday.
It was a very exciting experience.




Apparently the Humpbacks (these ones) are the only whales that leap (breach) from the surface like this.
We were about 4 KM off shore and watched the whales leaping every minute or so for over an hour while we were following a pod of juvenile males up the coast. They were real show offs.
The whales even swam under the boat and resurfaced in front of the bow and we could smell the air they expelled from the air hole on the top of their heads. The captain said they were unusually active on this occasion. We also had the benefit of a marine biologist on board, who gave us information about whales and their habits. I strongly suggest you take sea sickness tablets before taking a whale watching cruise. We were okay, but others did not fare as well.
We were on a three-hour round trip. The whales were still leaping as we reluctantly headed back to port. That evening we could see some whales breaching from the shore at Coolangatta, but they were a lot closer in the morning.
I went whale watching off Alaska a couple of years ago and Coolangatta was much more exciting. 
The Alaskan whales were smaller, and never breached, and only occasionally showed their tales before they dived down for several minutes.
Fare well till next time.
You can view a great action video of whales breaching at my friend's blog.

Saturday, 6 July 2013

My day at the Special Olympics Winter State Games 2013


July 5th 2013.
9.00am           
I wake when my son calls my name. My alarm hasn’t gone off. I am half an hour late already. Ten minutes later I start the car and we drive away. I am still eating a hastily peeled banana, doing up my vest and still without make-up. I have my vitamins in my pocket and a bottle of tap water. We drive within the speed limit to our destination across town.
10.00am
We arrive at our destination with plenty of time before the 11am start of the ten-pin bowling for Special Olympics Winter State Games. We purchase a hot drink and await the start of the event. We search and ask for a program for the day’s events to try and ascertain when my son’s event will occur. None is available.
11am
Everyone is at the venue. Nobody knows where he or she is assigned or when each is supposed to commence. A Power-Crazed Despot (PCD) whose role is to organise the players still has not posted a program. Everyone is dependent upon him to announce to which lane they are assigned. If they walk away they will not hear the announcement and will miss their call. Many are forced to stand, because there are insufficient chairs. We strain to hear his verbal pearls. Keep in mind that all these athletes have intellectual disabilities and some have hearing disabilities also.
11.30am
Some of the players commence practice and finally start the competition. Others still do not know where or when they will be bowling. PCD finally admits that the rest of the players will not start till after 1pm. I grit my teeth as I could have enjoyed another hour or two at home. I take my son for a walk, as the tension in the venue will only aggravate his anxiety. We buy lunch.
12.30pm
We return to the venue to find there is nowhere to sit and the games are running late. We go outside and sit in the car.
12.55pm
We go back inside because we don’t want to miss any announcement about new games. This time we take in our folding chairs. We find a corner in semi darkness and wait. Athletes, parents and carers cover every surface. I have a ding-dong confrontation with the PCD, but to no avail. He will not tell me when my son might expect to bowl. And he will not tell me when, after 9am tomorrow, we might expect to start the team bowling competition. My god! He has had all the names and stats for over a month to organise these 98 athletes!
1.55pm
My son’s name is called and he is assigned to a lane and commences practice. This lane, of course, is nowhere near where we were sitting, so I collect all our bags and chairs and try and find a position within sight of his lane. I find a spot behind people standing to watch the game. I can barely see the scoreboard. I cannot see the bowlers.
I watch. I talk to other distressed parents and carers. I wait. I have now been at the venue for just on four hours!
4.00pm
My son finally finishes his three games. We commence waiting for the results and presentations. Some other competitors have only recently commenced their games.
5.10pm
An announcement finally calls us to the café, where the results and presentations for my son’s grading will begin. Haggard athletes and carers jostle for position. A person without a loudspeaker shouts to announce the winners. My son gets second place. He is happy. I commiserate with others, who are still waiting for their events to end or their presentations to commence.
5.15pm
We drive home in the rain.
6.05pm
We arrive home. I still have not put on my make-up.

Total time bowling – 2 hours
Total time driving – 2 hours
Total time waiting – 5 hours!!!

Joy oh Joy! We get to do it all again tomorrow.

What could have happened?
  1. We could have had a program emailed or posted to all athletes and families before the day of the event. Everyone will make allowances for events running late, but we should not have to tolerate being treated like naughty children for having the temerity to ask what to expect. It is strange to me that the region that PCD is connected to, knew not to arrive till just before they would be bowling. Their athletes arrived calm and refreshed a short time before their games.
  2. We could have had a number of programs and lane allocations posted at the venue that athletes could follow and refer to, as required. None appeared.
  3. We could have been treated with respect for our time and effort to get there, instead of devaluing the time and commitment of athletes and their families. Sharing information and some preparation by PCD would have made everyone aware of where and when they were playing and improved the atmosphere greatly.
  4. When it is known that a crowd will be present for an event, additional chairs could be procured or hired, or attendees could be encouraged to bring suitable portable seating.
  5. Petty officials, who obviously have a chip on their shoulder, should not be allowed to continue in their role. Their manner makes it a frustrating and exhausting experience for all concerned.
Special Olympics Australia is a worthwhile and excellent organisation. My son has benefited from his participation. I have volunteered in various capacities. Unfortunately SO suffers from a lack of suitable officials, coaches and office bearers. Much falls to too few. A small number use their position to gather and hold power to the detriment of the whole organisation. It spoils the experience for all. It could, in time, tarnish the profile of the whole organisation, and also deter others from volunteering for these roles.

Friday, 24 May 2013

Sandcastles - Autism and Down syndrome



It is a hot, Melbourne, summer day some years ago.  Large chunks of the population have moved from the city to the bay side towns, along the Mornington and Bellarine Peninsulas to benefit from the coastal breezes.
My husband and I lounge on folding chairs in the shade of a boathouse, watching our two small boys playing in the sand. 
The elder boy, Duane, plays in the shallows like a beached whale and rolls his slick, wet body in the warm sand. He also enjoys toting buckets of seawater up the beach to watch the liquid disappear into the sand. His short, pudgy body waddles as his sand laden bathers sag beneath his crotch. He is content and happy in his activities.
The younger boy, Miles, is equally content to play alone. His solitary play is unlike his older half brother. Miles’ lightly tanned skin and agile body make him physically indistinguishable from other beach users, but this five year-old boy has autism. His repetitive activities are ritualised and obsessive. He sits in the shallows absorbed in the gentle lapping of the waves on the beach as he flaps his hands in excited delight. Then he moves to the dry sand and sifts handful after handful of the warm grains through his fingers, watching the play of light as the sand tumbles to the ground.
Duane moves towards other children as they enter the beach. His natural gregariousness impels him to seek playmates. His Down syndrome, is no impediment to his social urges and the other youngsters are unconcerned and accept him as he is. Soon he has gained their support to build the ‘biggest sand castle in the world’.
Meanwhile, Miles returns to the shallows to watch the waves lap against a small dinghy that is beached nearby. He gives no sign that he is aware of the noisy castle builders.
As parents we keep a watchful, yet lazy, eye on all the children as we enjoy the opportunity for quiet shared conversation. 
Two more sandy urchins approach our section of the beach. They walk along the shoreline collecting shells and other ‘treasures’. They could be brothers with their sun-bleached hair, bronzed, lean bodies and matching swimsuits. Nearing Miles they note his proximity to the dinghy and perhaps think they would like to float in the shallows, if given the chance. 
As the duo approach the lone water-watcher, my husband casually rises and ambles to a position close enough to assist any conversation, as Miles’ social skills are limited and his language consists of repeating the last few words he has heard, a characteristic known as Echolalia, common in children with autism.
Making conversation, the older of the two boys looks directly at Miles and asks, ‘Is this your boat?’
Miles barely acknowledges their existence. He remains with his back to the pair. He merely echoes, ‘Your boat.’
The first boy shields his eyes from the sun and leans impatiently closer. ‘No.  It’s not my boat. Is it your boat?’
Again the echo returns, ‘Your boat.’
His questioner shrugs and turns to his companion.
 ‘Let me try,’ says the second boy. ‘Is this your boat or somebody else’s?’
Immediately the echo returns, ‘Somebody else’s.’
The second boy smiles smugly. ‘See. I told you he didn’t know who owned the boat.’
They pass the water-watcher and move on to the castle builders. Soon they are enlisted to the common cause.
My husband returns to his chair, chuckling. As parents of children with disabilities, we sometimes become overwhelmed with the enormity of the task we face. 
Somehow Miles negotiated a situation, which could easily have sent him screaming from the beach. Instead he gave his parents a gift.
 ‘That’s the longest conversation he’s had so far!’ my husband reports gleefully. 
By Lisbeth Wilks 

Boiling the Peas - with a son with Autism



It was any other Saturday afternoon. I put a pot of frozen peas in water, onto the stove, ready for dinner on my return later in the day. Roy was gardening and Miles was on his regular railway jaunt. What could go wrong?

Next morning, we were having a rare breakfast together when I saw a piece of mustard coloured paper taped to the wall. It was attached with sticky tape, and was definitely out of place. It was at eye-level, near the switch for the overhead fan. Why was it stuck there?
As I walked towards the offending paper I said, ‘What’s this doing here?’
Suddenly I was aware of Miles’ face. His look of horror foretold that disaster might be in store, if I removed the paper. His fears held some foundation.
As I removed the paper a fist-sized hole was revealed in the plaster.
It was obvious who had performed this remodeling of the plaster, but why?
A forensic investigation was called for.
But first, my 32-year-old son with Autism had to learn (once more) that actions have consequences and that he would be responsible for paying for the wall to be repaired.
Keeping a straight face, the judgement was delivered and Miles retreated to his bedroom to tend his bruised ego and possibly comfort a sore hand.
A short time later, with an eye to detail and strategic questioning of my personal demolition subcontractor, I deduced the sequence of events that took place the previous day.
It appears that Miles returned elated from his day riding the rails and, for the first time in his life, decided to help get dinner ready. His effort in this respect was to turn on the stove under the peas. He then walked away. Pleased with his contribution to the smooth running of the household.
Sometime later, Miles returned to the kitchen to find the pot of peas boiling furiously and spilling over the stove. This was obviously not meant to happen.
Miles had the presence of mind to turn off the heat and remove the pot from the element. But this did not adequately remove the tension from the situation. Miles’ anxiety was now at the point of boiling over also.
To relieve the tension, Miles did something he rarely does. He hit something. That something was the wall. Usually walls are sturdy surfaces that can withstand a small pounding, but this wall collapsed under the force of his adult fist.
When Miles realised he had compounded his problem, he employed some problem solving skills we had not previously seen.
Miles went to his room and found a sheet of A4 paper that had nothing written or drawn on it. This, in itself, is a minor miracle. He then found a felt pen that he felt approximated the colour of the English mustard paint on the kitchen wall. He must have spent some time on this as he completely coloured that piece of paper with mustard ink.
The next step was simple. Attach the paper to the wall.
We always keep sticky tape around the house, so it was not difficult to locate the tape and use it to attach the paper to the wall.
Voila! Mum would never notice.
In fact his plan did work for about twelve hours.

Roy and I returned from our day’s activities.
I prepared dinner without noticing the peas had been pre-cooked.
The evening was spent in other areas of the house.
The next morning, when the evidence was revealed, the facts were so amazing that we saw humour in the incident.
The wall was patched, repaired and repainted.
Costs were covered.
Life goes on …

Lisbeth Wilks, 2011

Sunday, 12 May 2013

Dad's 'Bobby stories'


When I was a child my Dad’s bedtime stories were very popular.  They were all about his boyhood.  The stories usually involved his dog, ‘Bobby’, and came to be known as ‘Bobby Stories’.
Bobby was a middle sized brown dog of dubious parentage. He was skilled in bringing slippers and papers to his master and fetching sticks and balls.  Bobby’s loyalty was unquestioned.

Bobby with his master, Alex and his
three older sisters.

‘Bobby Stories’ made an impression on me and, when I had my own dog years later, I called him ‘Bobby’.
When we were feeling devilish, we teased dad to tell us the story about how his mother caught him sawing the legs of the dining room chairs. Dad feigned shock that we knew about this secret of his past, but he saw the funnier side of the anecdote.

Alex, at work with the toy saw. (Approx. 1914)

The Handkerchief


A simple everyday item, like a handkerchief, can send an unsuspecting sniffler time travelling to memories of childhood. Long forgotten times and incidents that lie buried in the subconscious for years can be carefully preserved within the folds of a thirty-centimetre square of linen. We keep articles of clothing or we grow out of them and pass them on. Occasionally we are the recipients of items from a relative or friend, that pass into our possession and lie in our drawers as small time capsules, waiting to explode their store of memories at unexpected times.

Betty and Alex on their wedding day, 1945.

That thankless task, the ironing, precipitated a rush of visions stored in the depths of my grey matter. I was ironing, with nothing to break the monotony. Between the shirts and jeans I extracted one of my husband’s handkerchiefs. He retains the old habit, looked upon favourably again by the environmentally conscious, of carrying pockets of hankies, for himself and forgetful family members. No tissues touch his gentle nose.  He always has a hanky in his pocket, after years of training by his mother.

I embarked upon the pile of handkerchiefs of various colours and stages of deterioration. Some barely a step away from tying up the tomato plants next summer. In the pile was a good quality, white linen handkerchief of the old style, with a half-inch hem and a blue ‘A’ embroidered in the corner. My husband’s name is does not start with ‘A’ and most of his handkerchiefs, if they have an initial, have an ‘R’. This handkerchief probably belonged to my father, Alexander. 

I am unsure how this handkerchief came into our possession. It may have been scooped up in the general cleanup after my parents died in late 1982. Probably shoved in a bag, or lost among the papers of his old roll top desk, or in the pocket of an item of clothing that has long since gone to the charity bin.

This the hanky could have been used to bandage those grazed knees that we had as children. Dad would lick the corner to clean up the wound and then carefully fold the handkerchief to bandage the afflicted knee or elbow, then, after working his minor miracle, he’d send us to mum for a more antiseptic treatment.

Was this the hanky Dad used to tie the knots in the corners to provide a hat on a hot summer day, when he was sitting on the beach before ‘Slip, Slop and Slap’?  He lay in the sun and baked like a beetroot, then rolled up his trouser legs and paddled in the bayside waters. I can’t remember him swimming. Just lying on the beach on one of those folding deck chairs, that you still see at old holiday homes along the Mornington Peninsula. Dad would read the newspaper, then fall asleep, and we would bury his pale, white feet in the cold, wet sand. His feet were the only thing that didn’t burn. He regretted his sun bake later when the sunburn glowed. Our childhood was full of the fishy smell of the ointment mum put on his and our burnt backs, legs and arms. 

Was this the handkerchief Dad tied two threepences into the corners for my sister or I to take to Sunday school? Our parents sent us to Sunday school without coming too. Did Dad know his daughters cashed the three-pence at the milk bar on the way to their Sunday appointment? Only two large brown pennies made it to the collection plate. 

Other memories of handkerchiefs flooded into my mind. Dad’s sneeze matched his rather large nose and large black eyebrows. He made a huge explosion when he feigned a sneeze into his large white hanky and then produced a penny, an Easter egg, or a lolly from behind the ear of a startled child. He would wave a hanky to attract our attention across a crowd of cousins, a signal to come and join an adventure, out the window or under the table. 

I remember my Mum borrowing one of Dad’s hankies to race at the annual Sunday school picnic. The picnic was in an open field. After the ride in the box-shaped furniture van, countless choruses of ‘Ten Green Bottles’, and sandwiches wrapped in the paper that used to come around the loaves of bread, there were races. Mum was not prepared to run fifty yards for the amusement of assorted, tired and sticky urchins. This was not the place for anything as serious as a running race. She made it a Dusting Race. My Mum lined up, and, with the help of Dad’s hanky, started ‘dusting’ her way to the finish. This was a curious surprise, as her housekeeping skills had not previously held such a high profile. Mum wasn’t lazy. She merely had other priorities.

A lowly handkerchief has many memories sewn into the flimsy fabric, a square of immortality, waiting to evoke long forgotten stories.

By Liz Wilks

Friday, 10 May 2013

The Carmichael Family of Stony Creek (South Gippsland)


The involvement of the Carmichael family with Stony Creek commenced with the marriage of John Carmichael and Isabella Campbell in 1846, in Shieldaig, in the highlands of Scotland.
The young couple emigrated to South Australia in 1849 with three children, Alexander, John and Michael. After the early death of Isabella, John and his young family unsuccessfully tried to make their fortue around the goldfields of Southern Australia.

The family grew up with little, if any, education and John (Jnr.) became a drover, teamster and a shearer, travelling the countryside to obtain work until the mid-1870s when he met and married Elizabeth Niven and settled in Berwick.

Around 1879 he, with many others, came into South Gippsland by way of Morwell and selected land in the East Dumbalk area. Upon grant of the land he works for the next couple of summers to clear a small portion, walking in from Mirboo North with supplies, as there was not sufficient feed to keep a horse on the propertyhe had named ‘Hilands’.

About 1882 he brought his wife and two young daughters to ‘Hilands’, going out to work clearing for neighbours and attempting to produce from his land enough to live on. He also worked with the survey teams , line clearing and helping clear the lines where the road now runs from Dumbalk East to Stony Creek.

The construction of the Great Southern Railway line, towards the end of the decade, gave him the opportunity to sell his produce (butter, eggs and meat) to the large numbers of railway workers camped along the line.

John, his father, joined John Jnr and his later death was the first burial in the Meeniyan Cemetery in 1894.

Margaret married Donald Henderson and lived on an adjacent property for a short time. Alexander lived most of his life at Dunkeld in Western Victoria.

John  and Elizabeth raised six daughters, Eva (Mrs W. Martin), Ilma (Mrs E. Wills), Belle (Mrs W. Barton), Janet (Mrs D. Coutts), Mollie (Mrs E. Gunson), Ruby (Mrs E. Campbell and three sons Duncan, Colin and John (known as Rod). Colin was killed in a fall from a horse at the age of 14.
Belle, with husband William Barton
Duncan, as well as being a farmer, was also a well-known livestock auctioneer in the Stony Creek and surrounding districts, prior to enlisting in the first AIF (Australian Infantry Forces) during the First World War. He ended the war with the rank of Lieutenant in the Fifth Light Horse Regiment. Mollie and Ruby also served overseas as nurses. (As a child, I remember Mollie and Ruby living in Melbourne in 1984 -LW).

Rod joined the bank in Stony Creek and later served at their branch at Terang, before returning home when Duncan enlisted.

After the war Duncan and Rod expanded operations of the family farm. They rented and bought properties around the district. They were mainly engaged in grazing sheep with large numbers of Merino wethers running on the plains country around the Stony Creek-Buffalo area, part of which had been selected by their father, in the name of one of his daughters.

Duncan and Rod were also very involved with football at Stony Creek. Duncan played in a premiership team in 1911 and 1920 and Rod was in the premiership team of 1920 also, and also in the Meeniyan-Stony Creek United premiership team of 1925. Their social life revolved around Stony Creek.

In the late 1920s they both married. Duncan Married Joyce Martin and they raised three children: Mollie (Mrs K. Day). John and Rory. After Duncan’s death in 1942, the family continued to farm until the 1960s, when they sold and moved from the area.  John (Rod) married Nina Helms and raised three children; Colin, Peter and Diane (Mrs D. James).

After World War Two, Rod and his sons, Colin and Peter, commenced clearing the country between Stony Creek and Buffalo. At the same time they became involved in the re-establishing of the Stony Creek Racecourse. Colin and Peter also played football with Stony Creek and Colin acted as secretary to the club for a year also.
The Grandstand at Stony Creek Racecourse in 1911.
Peter moved to Gloucester NSW in 1968. He had two sons, Rod and Lachlan.
Colin is still farming in the Stony Creek –Buffalo area. Colin had a son, Andrew. Andrew had a son, John. John is the fifth generation of Carmichael to have been born in Australia and to have lived in the Stony Creek area,

By Colin R Carmichael (1985)
‘Patanga Park’
Buffalo, Victoria, 3958

Belle's four eldest children
Hermia, Betty (Lisbeth), Phoebe and John
The three youngest children were
William, Duncan and Colin. (not pictured)

Alexander Geddes Senior - My elusive Grandfather


My memories of my grandfather, my father’s father, are of a thin, crotchety, bald man who spent much of his time in his garden, which was laid out with military precision. As a retired draper and small businessman, his home was still stacked with suitcases of linen sheeting, damask and other fabrics. Each case was labelled ‘Property of Alexander Geddes Esquire’.
            Alexander drove an immaculate car called a Graham Paige, which had a back seat like a Chesterfield couch. Sometimes, as a child, I sat in that car as it drove a slow and stately journey to the local shops or to church. It was the sort of vehicle that caused people to stop and look. It was already a vintage car in the 1950s.
Grandpa's Graham Paige
Grandfather was very old when I was very young. There was not much he had in common with a small girl, his adopted granddaughter. On one memorable occasion, a family argument resulted from him accusing me of breaking the seat in the outside toilet; something my mother admitted to doing while trying to admire his garden through the doorway. I regret that her admiration for the foliage did not wait until she had removed herself from the confines of the ‘smallest room’.
Alexander, Linda and Myrtle with Catherine and Alexander Snr, and Cousin Graeme
This petty incident, and the alleged matter of some money owed by my grandfather to my father, resulted in my parents not speaking to my Grandpa for many years.
When I next saw Alexander I was a teenager, ushered to his deathbed. He looked frail, in the large bed and darkened room. He barely acknowledged my father or I, although some truce had been called to accommodate this momentous occasion.
As years have passed I have wondered what was my grandfather’s background.
On my mother’s side of the family I was arrayed with intricate detail of the family history, especially the generations who came as settlers to the virgin Antipodes to farm tracts of land and produce large communicative families where everyone knew everyone else and saw each other regularly. Even on my paternal grandmother’s side the detail was available about settlers and farmers. But Alexander never offered information about his background, and I never asked.
Alexander and Catherine Geddes with their children: Alexander, Myrtle, Linda and Anne
By the time I became curious, it was too late. My parents’ generation had died. My two cousins on my father’s side seemed to have vanished. My only records of his existence were faded photographs and a photocopy of his marriage certificate.
From these meagre mementos I deduced that his mother’s name was Jane Paterson and his father was Thomas Geddes. His father was a miner in one of the hundreds of pits (coal mines) in Lanarkshire but he had already died by the time Alexander married. I do not know if Thomas and Jane were married.
Geddes drapery store in Melton
My grandfather was born in 1874 in Airdrie, within an area called Monklands which is part of the larger county of Lanarkshire. Alexander was born, raised and emigrated to Australia during the reign of Queen Victoria (1837 - 1901). He was a product of a time of stifling etiquette and class structure. As a miner’s son, he had no business having dreams beyond his station. Airdrie was then a village between Edinburgh and Glasgow in the Scottish Lowlands. 
It was recorded that Alexander was born on the thirteenth of August, but his superstitions caused him to always claim the fourteenth as his birthdate.  Apart from the record of Alexander’s birth, little else exists apart from his presence, recorded on the passenger list of the SS Australia, which left Brindisi, Italy in 1996 on route to Adelaide and Melbourne. He also voted in the 1899 Australian Federation Referendum where he was listed as a draper in Melton. The mystery remains.

Lisbeth Wilks